Re-Starting from scratch – A short post-mortem
Mar 18 2011
As Maxence said in the previous article, we decided after our last committee session to throw away our first concept. We thought it was the best option and we still think that way. Nevertheless, the second concept we made didn’t fit our expectations and we decided to start again… once more.
As a project manager, I have written this article in order to explain to you the troubles we encountered and the way we solved them. We are conscious that these two turnarounds sound strange, but please be sure that this concept is the best one or, at least, the last one. I promise.
Problems
The first main problem we encountered was related to our universe. We noticed – unfortunately, too late – that people were not yet ready to accept a surreal conception of the human body. The biology is a sensitive subject (especially when it is related to humans) we can’t freely play with. In fact, people rejected our concept because they couldn’t accept that a neuron could move through the organism. Moreover, they expected features and visual content which didn’t fit our intentions. To sum up, we designed a game that people were not ready to accept and enjoy.
The second problem was the lack of originality. Obviously, we focused on basic ideas which were used in a large range of games. Driving an avatar with fingers, using basic capacities to interact with the environment, fighting or avoiding enemies thanks to dexterity… it is definitely not revolutionary.
Lastly, we can’t hide that technology was a huge problem. The iPad is truly not an easy-to-use device for developers and we were forced to admit that it would have been impossible to reach our goals in graphic design. It can sound trivial, but the art direction of our concept was one of its USP and we were really disappointed on this point. Moreover, the short scene we managed to build and implement was not satisfying and had no personality.
A new start
Having identified all of these problems, we could start in another direction with more information. Firstly, we decided to get rid of the human body, which drove us to a dead-end. Our new concept would take place in another organism, animal, vegetal, extraterrestrial or, why not, an unidentified organic world. Moreover, we decided not to focus on scientific reality but to be free to design whatever we want.
We also forgot all of the constraints we were imposing on ourselves regarding the game design (e.g. entity management, dynamic and the maze-like environment) and we decided to explore new things that have not been really exploited on iPad. We wanted to differentiate ourselves from the huge list of puzzle and arcade games which have already been released on the appStore in order to give the player new experiences.
Then, we thought about the possible ways to make our game visually original and remarkable, among a lot of cartoon-style games.
